There once was a schoolgirl who was asked the question: “What is growth?” Considering the question for a second, she answered, “Growth is what happens while you sleep.” This is a good, down-to-earth answer from a bodily perspective, but I think there is a lot more to ponder here than even the girl herself realized. I believe she laid her finger on a profound answer to the much broader question: “What is growth as a full human being?” I do not mean to say that perfection of the human person occurs by taking power naps, although they certainly can be rejuvenating to man’s bodily life. Instead, I want to use man’s undisputed need for sleep as an analogy for his process of growth in other aspects of his life.
Sleep is necessary for man’s mental, physical, and spiritual well-being, hence we spend around a third of our lives sleeping (although the college years tend to skew the average). According to the Sleep Foundation, sleep “serves a variety of physical and psychological functions,” including restoration, maintenance, and augmentation of a person’s ability to learn, judge, and problem-solve; regulation of emotions; physical healing; maintenance of immune system function; and, of course, growth.1 These are all essential and healthy aspects of human life without which a person would be crippled in some way.
Consider, however, that although sleep is necessary to man’s full flourishing, proper sleep must be learned as a baby. The human being has the unique ability to choose to be something other than what he is naturally ordered to be. Isn’t it odd that man must be taught to be himself? That he, even if habituated to a healthy lifestyle, must choose to be himself? Babies at a certain age will often fight the sleep they need, even though they are objectively exhausted. The baby must learn to master his own life and existence by learning to sleep. In adults, however, this learned control may be used in unhealthy ways as well. To pursue our discussion of sleep, let us consider that when a person becomes self-conscious and capable of making informed choices, he may fight sleep when he fears for his safety in an unknown place. Alternatively, he may stay up late because he did not engage in the activities he wanted to enjoy during the day. These reactions stem from fear, in the first case, and self-fulfillment, in the second. Neither are necessarily bad in themselves, depending on the context. Yet, objectively, in each specific case, both impede the growth and healing of the person which sleep enables. These examples are not meant to condemn babies or night owls. The point is that man finds in his everyday life a strange phenomenon: a process of growth and healing which is strictly indispensable to his flourishing, yet which he has some power to control.
This discussion of man’s active control over his life and man’s dependence on passive sleep introduces a paradox. Man has the ability and need to choose his way of life, and yet his nature demands that he give up conscious control of it in sleep—for what is precisely given up in sleep is man’s choice, his control over his actions. This necessary action requires two intertwined qualities on man’s part: trust and vulnerability. A person must trust that he is safe to fall asleep in a particular place. He must risk the possibility of bodily injury during his sleep, in order that he may reap the benefits of sleep. This core paradox of human life, seen in sleep, applies to the rest of his life: that to become perfect, man must give up his control, be it of his consciousness, or of his attention, or of his very self.
Particularly relevant to this day and age, the paradox of sleep and control applies to man’s interaction with technology.
This claim may seem strange. To apply the image, a further step must be made from the surrender of consciousness in sleep (which is biologically inevitable) to the analogous surrender of attention in our conscious life. In sleeping, we inevitably acquiesce to our biological makeup and give up consciousness, allowing growth and healing. In attending to reality as something outside of us, however, we acquiesce to reality and consequently give up a comfortable but illusory notion of self-as-in-control, allowing real growth and formation in the real world by becoming vulnerable. This sacrifice of control allows the real world to act on the person and perfect him according to its kind, which it would not be able to do if the person ignored or attempted to control it via technology. In this way, the sacrifice of attention to reality is illustrated by sleep. Like sleep, it is an “all-in” investment, which reaps a rich harvest. On the other hand, in doomscrolling or any excessive technology use, the true self becomes “sleep-deprived,” denied the restful abandonment it needs for flourishing by locking itself in an attention echo-chamber, totally in control of its little screen-and-button world.
This kind of attending to the other that is necessary for true self-growth applies peculiarly to the appreciation of mimetic art, which is itself a man-made reality. In attending to a work of art, especially a story, a person becomes immersed in the artistic reality — he must stand outside himself — in the Greek, ek-stasis, ecstasy. Upon the full completion of a person’s artistic experience, be it the image of some object or the portrayal of some character, the person often experiences a kind of “waking up,” (most noticeable, in my experience, at the end of an engrossing film). I would argue that this “waking up” is inseparable from the impact which a good work of art has in an individual’s soul. Why? To experience catharsis is to experience a purgation and rejuvenation of soul (or perhaps it is like having your mental lawn mowed); to be purged is to be passive to the action of some other; and this passive state of reception and rejuvenation recalls the notion of sleep. True catharsis is only possible when the subject’s self “falls asleep” in the work of art, awakening at the end to a cleansed appreciation for the life he is living in the present moment.
The notion of losing oneself in sleep to find oneself runs so deeply in the human condition that at the most basic spiritual level, man must not merely sleep but die to self. It’s fundamental Catholic spirituality. In dying to himself for love of another, man is enriched and, in fact, only unlocks the riches of the beloved insofar as he opens himself up to the other. It is this mystery that man experiences in communion with Christ: “for whoever would save his life will lose it; and whoever loses his life for my sake, he will save it.”2 One’s life, given up totally but intentionally, will be saved in the Resurrection of Jesus Christ. Here, the natural image of growth through sleep gives way to the mysterious supernatural image of resurrection through death. This mind-bending concept poses a dilemma; after all, while all animals die, man’s soul is indestructible, on account of his rationality. Yet he does die, and nothing resurrects by nature. This paradox is impossible to fully reconcile in the human mind—but we can come to understand it better if we can compare it to a parallel phenomenon on our natural level. And so I will leave you with this image: waking up, some peaceful morning, from a sound sleep to see the golden sunrise bathing your bedroom wall. You drink in the moment, refreshed but not ready to get up yet. And you remember it’s Sunday. ![]()
_____________________________
1. “Why do we need sleep?” https://www.sleepfoundation.org/how-sleep-works/why-do-we-need-sleep.
2. Luke 9:24 (RSV).
