When I was Anglican, we sang traditional hymns at the beginning and end of each service as the priest entered and exited with the cross. However, during the Offertory and Communion, the congregation sang contemporary Christian music, also known as praise and worship. Over time this combination of music struck me as less and less fitting for a traditional-style Anglican service. The Anglican Church was founded on certain Catholic liturgical traditions, as Henry VIII intended, but of course, the Church of England over time developed its own traditions. It is not my intention to go into detail about these traditions. Rather my fundamental point is that the mixture of “praise and worship” with hymnography created and continues to create a disorderly impression unfitting for the liturgy.   

After leaving the Anglican Church and eventually attending an Eastern liturgical service, I felt this unfamiliar Byzantine form of liturgy fed the human soul properly. Instead of guitars and drums, I encountered chanting and hymns. This latter form of music seemed much more suited for the Lord’s House, for the Temple of God serves as a refuge from the commotion of the outside world. Abrasive drums and heavily strummed guitar conflicted with the tranquility of the church, whereas the gentle lull of chant seemed to resonate there. Thus, in the Byzantine church, I felt much more at peace, much more at home. 

After having experienced this difference, the following questions pressed upon my mind: How could anyone spiritually ascend higher to the angelic choirs with praise and worship? Does praise and worship rightly belong in a high church setting? To answer these questions, first, it seems proper to return to the fundamentals of early Church musical practice and theology. 1 Peter 2:5 says, “You also, like living stones, are being built into a spiritual house to be a holy priesthood, offering spiritual sacrifices acceptable to God through Jesus Christ” (NIV).  This places a high standard on right worship. Musical worship should remind the faithful of the angelic choir that participates in saying, “Holy, Holy, Holy, Lord of Hosts, heaven and earth are full of your glory.” This very verse is sung in the “Sanctus” in the Roman Rite and in the Anaphora in the Eastern Liturgy of St. John Chrysostom. This is why in both the Catholic and Eastern Church, hymnography matters—they all treasure Byzantine chant, Gregorian chant, and traditional church hymns because this type of music is modelled to participate with the heavenly choir.   

Another reason chant should be favored over praise and worship is that the Church must protect itself from the influence of secular society. Indeed, some contemporary music reflects pop culture music more than it does sacred music. Peter Kwasniewski asserts In Sacred Music vs. Praise and Worship, “it is especially important that liturgical music both be and seem to be exclusively connected with and consecrated to the liturgy of the Church. If the musical style is borrowed from the outside world and brought into the temple, it profanes the liturgy and harms the spiritual progress of the people.” Praise and worship has its place, and the intention behind it is assuredly well-placed. However, the liturgy does not seem to be the appropriate setting for this type of worship. 

Moreover, praise and worship is a highly sentimental music form. The worship of the Catholic and Orthodox Church filled with hymns and chants transcend contemporary trends, lift the human soul upward to rest in contemplating and exalting in the beauty and holiness of an eternal God. Contemporary music keeps the spirit in a lower state of emotional release. Fr. Lawrence Farly on his blog No Other Foundation goes so far as to say that modern praise and worship of the contemporary movement can manipulate the passions; it introduces a fast arousal of emotions, giving people a positive, yet momentary psychological rise. When used in the liturgy, this type of music shifts the focus from praising God to a focus on oneself and one’s emotions about God, which is problematic.   

In the early Church, the Fathers specifically decided to move away from this type of evocative music. They avoided instruments such as drums, harps, and lyres in favor of acapella chanting. They thought that this former type of music could invoke sensuality like that found in pagan revelries, whereas chant was reminiscent of the Old Law practiced by the Jews. Largely played on drums and strings, praise and worship is more like the pagan music of old than the music of the Old Testament. Robert Arraki, an online Orthodox dialoguer with Protestants, asserts in his article “Orthodox Worship Versus Contemporary Worship,” “The Evangelical approach to worship seems to assume that Jesus abolished the Old Testament….The paucity of New Testament passages on worship has been taken as grounds for an anything goes approach to worship.”  He goes on to comment how Christ did not break off from the Old Testament but fulfilled the Old in the New Covenant. At the end of his article, Arraki says that the danger of Pentecostal and contemporary music is that it increasingly lets loose charismatic effects, such as “holy laughter,” etc. Thus, this kind of music puts greater emphasis on God’s effects rather than on God in Himself. Therefore, traditional hymns should be the standard for the holy Mass, lest we begin worshipping God’s miracles, in favor of worshipping God Himself. 

To guard against this possibility, I propose solutions such as prayer for the unity of all believers into one church preserving pure worship, interacting with Protestants, and telling them the richness that awaits those who step into a church filled with choral hymns and chant, untainted by the contemporary movement.