My parents told me about Santa Claus, but whenever my siblings or I directly asked whether Santa was real they would always redirect to St. Nicholas. There was no observable or intentional pedagogy about how Santa was presented to us: we read A Special Place for Santa and watched the old CCC St. Nicholas cartoon (which is still worth a watch today), but also read or watched the more secular Santa stories, including the Rankin-Bass origin story, Santa Claus Is Coming to Town. We left out the milk and cookies, as well as some carrots on the porch for the reindeer. 

My discovery of Santa’s nonexistence occurred in the following manner. Around my ninth or tenth year, I had deduced– child prodigy that I was– the improbability, if not the impossibility, of the Easter Bunny’s existence. I summoned my father from his work desk with a tone clearly showing that the matter we were about to discuss was one of grave import. Standing around the pool table in the basement, out of earshot of the rest of the children, I presented the evidence. However, my father must have overestimated my deductive skills, because he not only agreed but added that Santa Claus wasn’t real either. 

I was shocked. I left the room in a mood of somber melancholy, my triumph of intellect sullied by this wholly unexpected revelation. Even years later my father was embarrassed by the episode. This begs the question: what made Santa different from the Easter Bunnies, Tooth Fairies, and assorted imaginary friends, playmates, and beasties that occupy a child’s imagination?

I believe it had something to do with the unique sense of wonder and gift that Santa represents in the child’s world. Allow me to explain: little children expect a great deal of things from their parents. So much of a child’s life is dictated by his parents. What to wear, when and what to eat, where to go, and when to sleep provide the structure of the child’s first interaction with the world. Anyone who has been near a small child, or even those who only know of the little fiends from blood-curdling stories of “the terrible twos,” know that children take for granted many of the sacrifices that their parents make for them. This applies to nearly every person or interaction in the child’s life. 

But Santa Claus is different. At least for my family, there would be some gifts wrapped under the tree, and the gifts from Santa would come in the stocking. Those gifts were usually the things my parents knew we wanted most or had specifically asked for. And those gifts were usually the most exciting, not only because they were often the things we wanted most, but because they came from someone beyond the small circle of benefactors whom we took for granted. If done properly, this can inculcate a sense of wonder, and enhances the child’s incipient receptiveness to the world which one discovers in greater detail as one grows older. And when the child finds out it’s his parents, if revealed at the right time, the initial disappointment transitions into a deeper appreciation of what your parents had already done for you and what you had taken for granted when younger, which can further your sense of gratitude. 

Which brings me to my argument: when done properly, Santa Claus does not detract from the mystery of the Incarnation, but rather enhances it and can bear good fruit in a child’s soul that long outlasts a literal belief in the jolly old elf. The love of God is something that ought never be taken for granted, but, like the love of one’s parents, it often can be. The pious awe that can move an older soul to tears in adoration, a soul that has seen and experienced the drama of salvation play out within its very self, is not fully developed in most adults, let alone most children. But a child can easily understand a present. Grace builds on and perfects nature, and a soul inculcated to approach the world as a gift will be fertile ground to receive the Gospel. Of course, Santa should never distract from the true “reason for the season,” but he can be incorporated to shed light on that reason in a way particularly suited to the dispositions and developmental stage of a child. If the family is meant to be a reflection of the Trinity, then surely a family’s practices can, in some small way, mimic a parable.