Few can say that they altogether love the place they are from, much less are in love with it. Yes, we’re proud to be Americans, but that isn’t what I mean. In our thoughts and feelings toward our hometowns, our native places, something is often missing. Our homes seem hardly worth loving. A friend of mine says that his city has a good Catholic community but not much else worth sticking around for. Another friend describes where he’s from as only a place of drug addiction and vice. A third has nothing to say at all about his native place. Some people have a certain pride in their heritage, if they happen to be from a place with a strong personality, but with constant moving resulting in a lack of roots, the average person does not have much care at all for his home.  

What causes this attitude and why is it harmful? Some forces and circumstances bear more blame than others. The modern ease of movement has its hand in things. The development of communication has led to greater connection with the world beyond one’s neighborhood and thus has shifted people’s attention past what is right in front of them. Today, many people pursue the bulk of their friendships online, whether or not they first met their friends there. Following more national and international news has in turn de-emphasized local news, and the cycle of losing focus on one’s native place continues. The harm caused is this: a growing cancer of indifference in the hearts of men. It is not pronounced, it is not loud, and it certainly is not recognized as cancerous. The indifference is only quiet because it is present in so many hearts that we might begin to call it healthy. Dig deep within yourself, and I suspect you will find it too, to a greater or lesser extent. On a careful examination, we will find that we really don’t care for Raleigh, or Great Falls, or Winston-Salem, or Alexandria. As long as we don’t, nothing will get better.  That’s the tragedy of Pimlico. 

In Chesterton’s Orthodoxy, he portrays to the reader a peculiarly “desperate thing” called Pimlico.1 For the longest time, I didn’t know anything about Pimlico except that it was some place in England and, apparently, an awful one at that. It does not really matter where or what Pimlico is; when we read Chesterton’s words about it, we will see that we know the place all too well.  

Chesterton gives three ways that we can approach thinking of a place: we can approve of it, we can disapprove of it, or we can love it. He finds that it is insufficient to approve or disapprove of some place if we actually want to will its good. He uses Pimlico, a then rundown part of London, to illustrate his point. If a man only disapproves of its sordid state, “he will merely cut his throat or move to Chelsea.” It remains unchanged. His dwelling place stays exactly the same. But it is not enough either to approve of it, “for then it will remain Pimlico, which would be awful.” Both of these responses are properly called indifference, as said above. Everyone has an opinion about their home, good or bad, but many are nevertheless largely indifferent. Approval and disapproval solve nothing and lead only to the exact decay that we see now.  

There is a way out, a third option: to love. Chesterton spends plenty of time on this point for good reason. The love he is describing is not related to some earthly cause or reason; in fact, it can’t be. If I “love” Great Falls, Montana for its public parks and they are then rezoned into housing, I lose the so-called “love” that I had before and no longer care for my hometown. Chesterton describes the proper love as “arbitrary,” “with a transcendental tie and without any earthly reason.” Most poignantly, he says that a man should love his home “as mothers love children, arbitrarily, because it is theirs.” This love is the only way that things get better, that places change. Approval and disapproval avail nothing and could never make anywhere great. Chesterton writes that “if there arose a man who loved Pimlico, then Pimlico would rise into ivory towers and golden pinnacles. . . Pimlico in a year or two might be fairer than Florence.” In your mind, as in many others, there is probably a rising incredulity that this ennobling of Pimlico is far from the truth. Chesterton’s response? He gives his oft quoted words: “Men did not love Rome because she was great. She was great because they had loved her.” Human history and all of the greatness of cities and nations are founded on the love that a man had for his home. 

Pimlico is not a subsection of London; it is your home. That man is not someone else; it is you. Level every objection you wish against it: “God doesn’t call everyone to stay where they are, I can choose where I go, there can’t really be hope for my native place.” And yet… and yet… if there arose a man who loved it, Pimlico could change. Wherever your dwelling place has been or is, could become good, lovely, and holy. If it has never been much, it could become great. If it has fallen from grace, its embers could be rekindled. This is not just about temporal greatness, but about the soul, spirit, and culture of a place. All things can be restored in Christ, but I wager it is not done by drifting across the country. It is done by taking a stand and saying, “Here is my home. It is not much; it is rough around the edges and to be honest, it stinks. But here, right here, is the place I choose to love because it is mine. If I do not love it, then who will? I will love it, and only then will the change begin.”  

 

1 Orthodoxy, in Basic Chesterton (Springfield, IL: Templegate Publishers, 1984), 49. All subsequent citations are from this same place.